Omakaase vs 1st on the List: Which SEO Agency is the Better Fit?
1st on the List brings 25+ years of SEO experience. Omakaase offers AI-native execution and multi-market coverage. Here's an honest look at both.
1st on the List: Canadian SEO agency with over two decades of organic search experience
Honest comparison — we acknowledge where 1st on the List wins.
1st on the List is a Canadian SEO agency that has been operating since 1997 — one of the original search engine optimisation firms in North America. Their longevity is genuine, and they have a track record that spans algorithm changes, platform shifts, and the full evolution of organic search. Omakaase is newer, but built with a fundamentally different infrastructure: AI-native workflows, programmatic content at scale, and a full-service model covering paid media and web design alongside organic.
Side-by-side breakdown
Omakaase
Newer agency — 40+ documented case studies, growing portfolio
1st on the List
25+ years in SEO — one of the longest-operating North American SEO agencies
Omakaase
Built from the ground up on AI-assisted workflows and programmatic content systems
1st on the List
Traditional SEO methodology — tested and proven but not AI-native
Omakaase
SEO, paid media, web design, social media — all channels integrated
1st on the List
SEO and web design — limited paid media and social capability
Omakaase
Month-to-month rolling contracts — no lock-in
1st on the List
Typically 6-month minimum commitments
Omakaase
US, UK, Germany, France, Spain, Netherlands — purpose-built for multi-market
1st on the List
Canada and US domestic focus; limited European capability
Omakaase
AI-accelerated content and programmatic page generation at scale
1st on the List
Manual content strategy — proven quality but slower production
Omakaase
Pricing published upfront; proposal builder provides costs in minutes
1st on the List
Custom quotes; no public pricing
Omakaase
From £1,800/$2,200/month — designed for SMBs and growing businesses
1st on the List
Flexible pricing tiers; accessible to smaller businesses
The verdict
1st on the List is a credible choice if you value longevity and a proven track record across many algorithm cycles, and are primarily operating in Canada and the US. Omakaase is the better fit if you need AI-accelerated delivery, multi-channel coordination beyond organic search, European market coverage, or month-to-month contract flexibility.
Frequently asked questions
How long has 1st on the List been in business?
1st on the List was founded in 1997, making them one of the longest-operating SEO agencies in North America. Their team has seen virtually every major algorithm change and platform shift in search history. Omakaase is a newer agency — but built from the start on AI-native infrastructure that older agencies are still adapting to.
Does 1st on the List offer paid media and social management?
1st on the List focuses primarily on SEO and web design. Their paid media and social media offerings are limited. If you need a single agency managing organic, paid, and social cohesively, Omakaase's integrated model is a more practical choice.
Is Omakaase available for Canadian businesses?
Yes — Omakaase works with businesses across North America including Canada, as well as the UK and European markets. If you are a Canadian company with ambitions in the UK or European markets, Omakaase's multi-market infrastructure is a direct advantage over agencies focused on the North American domestic market.
Ready to see what Omakaase can do for you?
Build a custom proposal in 60 seconds — no sign-up, no sales call required. See exactly what you would get and at what price.
Build my proposal